Send Them Back: Trump’s Deportation Demand for Two Muslim Lawmakers Collides With the 14th Amendment Omar adds another word Fabricator!.
Within moments, both women exit the chamber, their kick complete. What followed over the coming 24 hours would transfigure a moment of congressional dissent into a indigenous extremity. On Truth Social, Trump demanded the” rapid-fire expatriation” of the two Muslim lawgivers, writing.
When people can bear like that, and knowing that they’re Crooked and loose Politicians, so bad for our Country, we should shoot them back from where they came as presto as possible”.
There’s only one problem with this demand.
Rashida Tlaib was born in Detroit, Michigan. She has been an American citizen her entire life. Ilhan Omar, while born in Somalia, has held U.S. citizenship for nearly three decades. Under the 14th Correction to the U.S. Constitution, neither can be deported — to Somalia, to Palestine, or anywhere differently.
Trump’s demand collides with 157 times of indigenous precedent. And in that collision lies a story about the limits of presidential power, the protections of citizenship, and a nation formerly again divided over who truly belongs.
The Protest What happed in the Chamber
The battle did n’t crop from nowhere. Trump’s speech concentrated heavily on his administration’s immigration crackdown, which has redounded in at least eight deaths in Immigration and Customs Enforcement detention centers since the launch of 2026, following at least 31 deaths last time.
Fortified civil agents had been stationed in Minnesota, Omar’s home state, grounded on allegations of fraud within Somali communities — allegations
Rights groups say have been used to unfairly target emigrants.
When Trump invited members of Congress to stand and show support for his immigration programs, Republicans rose. Egalitarians remained seated. Trump responded from the tribune” You should be shamed of yourselves”.
That is when Tlaib and Omar cried back.
” You’re killing Americans!” they repeated, representing the deaths in ICE guardianship. Omar added her blameworthiness that Trump was a” fabricator”. After their brief outburst, both lawgivers exited the chamber, leaving behind a stupefied silence and, moments latterly, a furious chairman.
The Demand” shoot Them Back”
On Wednesday morning, Trump took to Truth Social. His post was characteristically unrestrained, describing the two lawgivers as having” the bulging, bloodshot eyes of crazy people, fools, mentally crazed and sick who, honestly, look like they should be institutionalized”.
Also came the operative line” We should shoot them back from where they came as presto as possible.
The phrasing was nearly identical to a 2019 tweet
In which Trump told four Popular legislators of color — including Omar and Tlaib — to” go back” to their countries. At the time, the House suggested to condemn his commentary as supremacist. Now, seven times latterly, he’d escalated from suggestion to demand, from” go back” to” shoot them back.”
Tlaib’s response came fleetly on X.” Can not take two Muslimas talking back and correcting him so now he’s crashing out.#PresidentMajnoon,” she wrote, using an Arabic word meaning” frenetic” king.
The indigenous Wall The 14th Amendment Explained
Trump’s demand collides with a indigenous provision that has stood for over a century and a half. The 14th Correction, ratified in 1868 in the fate of the Civil War, begins with a judgment of profound clarity
All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the governance thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they live.
This language was designedly chosen to capsize
The Supreme Court’s ignominious Dred Scott decision, which had held that people of African descent could n’t be American citizens. The correction’s framers intended to establish formerly and for all that birth on American soil confers American citizenship — period.
Rashida Tlaib was born in Detroit. She’s thus, by the plain textbook of the 14th Correction, a citizen. Ilhan Omar was born in Somalia but naturalized nearly three decades ago; she too is a citizen under the correction’s alternate clause.
Readmore Peskov’s Pledge, Washington’s Doubt: Why the Kremlin’s Nuclear
As New Jersey Attorney General Matthew
Platkin said in a separate legal environment,” Birthright citizenship has been part of the fabric of this nation for centuries. And it was put in the Constitution 157 times ago when the people of this nation said we were no longer going to let the political vagrancies determine whether or not someone born
On United States soil is an American citizen”.
The Supreme Court has upheld this interpretation multiple times, dating back to an 1898 ruling that verified the citizenship of a man born in San Francisco to Chinese indigenous parents.
The Broader Assault Birthright Citizenship Under Siege
Trump’s demand regarding Tlaib and Omar is n’t an insulated incident. It’s part of a broader crusade against birthright citizenship that has defined his alternate term.
On his first day back in office, January 20, 2025,
Trump issued an administrative order named” guarding the Meaning and Value of American Citizenship”. The order directed civil agencies to refuse recognition of citizenship for U.S.- born children whose parents are n’t citizens or legal endless residers including those present unlawfully and those with temporary legal status.
